extra credit 2

I watch The Business of Amateurs documentary for my second extra credit project. Although this did not really deal with race that much, it still gave a lot of insight into the NCAA and their corrupt nature from the start. It is just mind-blowing the number of athletes that leaving college sports with debilitating injuries, mental and physical, leaving them unable to hold a job. Junior Seau, a former player, said that he believes that his medical bills post-graduation outweighed the cost of his education. It is not uncommon for players to get injured, continue playing, and then cause a tremendous amount of wear and tear on their injury. One of the players, waited one year until going to an out of university doctor to learn that his knee was torn and that he will need surgery. Since he went out of the school, he was responsible for all the medical bills associated with the injury, even though it was the school's misdiagnosis that led him to that state of his injury. One man that was interviewed (i forgot his name) was talking about the tremendous number of athletes that develop severe depression and anxiety due to their brain injuries and resort to drinking and pain meds, often leading to suicide. Sadly, this former athlete fell into the same hole one year later.
Another interesting statistic was that the average football player is worth 137,000$/yr and the average basketball player is worth 290,000$/yr meanwhile the average scholarship amount is 23,000$/yr. With this, the NCAA creates this absurd wording in everything they release about these athletes and how everything they do is for the athletes and all of the money goes towards them. One of the quotes that really grinded my gears was when the NCAA stated in one of their advertisements that "student-athletes should be protected from exploitation by commercial advertisements" and then the girl commented on it and said "what they are really doing is protecting others from the talent the NCAA is commercially exposing." Disgusting!
The other interesting scandal was the one associated with UNC, where they would throw all the Black student-athletes into the same "African American Studies" major where they would be provided with the answers to the exams, and in other classes, all they had to do was write a paper. This was called a Paper Class, a class created to keep important athletes in the GPA range to play their sport. Essentially, this was a guaranteed A with nearly no work. The sad part about this is that these players are tricked into believing that they are getting a scholarship to get an education meanwhile they are getting a scholarship to play for a team that is going to make hundreds of thousands of dollars off of you.

Here is the trailer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SGtoOFoEuM 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HELLO WELCOME TO MY RESEARCH IDEAS BLOG     On the Privatization OF COLLEGEEEE!!!!! Idea #1- College Sports        Athletes many times go to school for free        California recently legalized paying college athletes- big controversy         A lot of money goes into it        Large factor of where students choose to go to school, ex. schools down south are bigger on sports Idea #2- undecided
Read more

counter argument

Argument- Black student-athletes are treated as Migrant Laborers exploited for their athletic ability by the NCAA via the Plantation Model.  The leverage of the NCAA over these athletes stems from the overemphasis of sports in black communities leading to an enormous pool of overzealous applicants each year. Counter- Despite the corrupt nature of the NCAA, it provides players with a form of self-empowerment through academic achievement and the overall feeling of self-worth (especially if you are the first person in your family to graduate college). It also helps one build an identity and help make connections in the world beyond a small community. Overall, gaining a college degree, in general, is very beneficial in today's society and incrementally benefits those of low-income families more than those of the middle class. Additionally, there is always the chance of falling into the one percent that makes it and succeeds in the NFL/NBA and gets paid millions of dollars.
Read more
I would like to narrow down my research paper to whether college athletes should get paid and talk about the state of California being the first to allow this, even though it does not go into effect until 2023. I will look in to see if other states are willing to follow in the footsteps of California. If so why or why not. A common argument for not getting paid is that these athletes are putting everything of theirs on the line - their physical health, mental health, their future careers (if sports does work out), and lastly, their time. With this also comes the question of should they get paid for commercials/ brand deal at least since it is essentially face and their brand. Can college pay athletes for one and not the other? The other argument is that when it comes down to it, college is a place for education and many times, these high ranked athletes are going and getting degrees at the major universities for free. Is that not enough to count as a salary? https://www.npr.org/2019/
Read more